Saturday, April 19th, 2014

Canadian Politicians Without a Queue

4

When you think about our universal health care system do you ever wonder about the fairness of waiting lists, otherwise known as queues? Our politicians claim queues provide Canadians with equal access to health care. Do they really?

Remember the recent outcry when hockey players and their families jumped the queue for the H1N1 flu vaccine? I don’t understand why that caused such a stir because athletes, like politicians, always receive preferential treatment. Do you honestly think that any of them wait months on a list for an MRI or surgery? 

How can you be considered a queue-jumper if you are never really in the queue to begin with? In 2007 former prime minister Jean Chretien discussed his medical symptoms while playing a round of golf with a Cardiologist. He received testing the next day that revealed arterial blockage. Media reported that a cardiologist then requested emergency quadruple heart bypass surgery for the following day. This swift access to testing and surgery helped prevent heart damage from occurring. The Montreal Heart Institute denies that Chretien received any special treatment indicating that all of their patients receive the same standard of care. Oh, really? How many other patients are able to schedule their emergency surgery? On December 11, 2007 Chretien appeared on the CBC television show The Hour with George Stroumboulopoulos.

In the first two minutes of the interview we learn that after receiving the results of his tests Chretien was told that he would need surgery at some point in the future. His response was that he’d like to have it right away and they agreed to perform it the next morning. When asked why he didn’t have to wait on a list like everybody else he attributes it to luck. The truth is that luck has very little to do with it.

While on the campaign trail in 2006, the media reported that New Democratic Party (NDP) leader Jack Layton received a hernia operation in the 1990′s at the Shouldice hospital, a private facility in Toronto. An interesting choice for such a fierce defender of the public health care system. Then again, if labour unions helped found your political party then I suppose you are beholden to them politically not personally.    

The truth is that universal health care and its queues do not provide each of us with equal access when it comes to caring for our health. In a 2005 judgment, the Supreme Court of Canada confirmed that “Access to a waiting list is not access to care”. The shameful part is that politicians continue to shape our health policy and promote a public health care system whose shortcomings they will never experience.

Comments

4 Responses to “Canadian Politicians Without a Queue”
  1. Ronal Morse says:

    What incredible luck to have surgury so fast, the only way for the general public to get surgury done so fast is if we need

    A) A vascetomy

    B) Female tubes tied or womb removal (hysterectomy)..

    Anything else generally is a long long wait.

    Amazing.

  2. Dashing Leech says:

    Anecdotal stories do not make statistics. If politicians are getting preferential treatment, you need to show it statistically. The father of a friend of mine went into the ER a few weeks ago and got emergency surgery the next day.

    From the sounds of it, Chretien actually needed emergency surgery too. Not only are you missing statistics, you are missing actual diagnoses and instead inserting anecdotal stories and insinuation in their place. That’s hardly convincing of anything.

    • admin says:

      Dashing Leech,
      Jean Chretien is a case in point – the point being that our health care queues do not provide all Canadians with equal access to care based on need. Unlike your friend’s father, who entered the emergency department, Jean Chretien was able to bypass the emergency department queue. You’re right, reliable statistics showing the prevalence of preferential access to care would be helpful although it may be difficult to collect and report data on Canadians who never enter the queue. Let me know if you come across any updated statistics on the subject and I’ll update the post.

Trackbacks

Check out what others are saying about this post...
  1. [...] health care. It may be easier for some politicians to justify leaving the country rather than jumping the queues within it. Williams, like many before him, is exercising an individual freedom of choice in health [...]



Speak Your Mind

I have read, understood, and agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy of The Patient Factor website, and I am posting this content in accordance with the terms and conditions set out in the Terms of Service. I accept full responsibility for any content I post, and hereby consent to the publication of this content and its disclosure to the public on The Patient Factor website.



webdesign by Linda Caroll Copyright © 2009 Chapman Communication Sitemap / Privacy / Terms of Use
Canadian Health Care; News, Views and Commentary